Skip to content

AI-Assisted Development Guidelines

This document establishes best practices and guidelines for using AI tools in academic web development projects, based on the experience of developing this Research Data and Methods Workshop Series website.

Overview

AI-assisted development can significantly enhance productivity and quality in academic web projects when implemented with proper oversight, transparency, and ethical considerations. These guidelines ensure responsible use of AI tools while maintaining academic integrity and quality standards.

Core Principles

1. Transparency and Attribution

Full Disclosure

  • Clearly document all AI tools used in the development process
  • Specify AI models, versions, and service providers
  • Distinguish between AI-generated and human-created content
  • Maintain detailed records of AI assistance throughout the project

Proper Attribution

  • Credit AI tools in project documentation
  • Include AI assistance in acknowledgments where appropriate
  • Follow institutional guidelines for AI attribution
  • Respect intellectual property and licensing requirements

2. Human Oversight and Quality Assurance

Continuous Review

  • Every AI-generated output must be reviewed by qualified humans
  • Implement systematic quality control processes
  • Validate technical accuracy and academic standards
  • Ensure compliance with accessibility and usability requirements

Expert Validation

  • Subject matter experts should review content accuracy
  • Technical experts should validate code quality and security
  • Academic standards should be verified by qualified reviewers
  • User experience should be tested with real users

3. Academic Integrity

Ethical Use

  • Comply with institutional AI policies and guidelines
  • Respect copyright and intellectual property rights
  • Maintain academic honesty in all AI-assisted work
  • Follow disciplinary standards for AI use in research

Quality Standards

  • Maintain the same quality standards as non-AI-assisted work
  • Ensure AI assistance enhances rather than replaces human expertise
  • Validate all claims and information provided by AI tools
  • Apply critical thinking to all AI-generated suggestions

Implementation Guidelines

Pre-Development Planning

Define Scope and Boundaries

  • Clearly identify which tasks will use AI assistance
  • Establish quality criteria and review processes
  • Define roles and responsibilities for human oversight
  • Set up documentation and tracking systems

Tool Selection

  • Choose AI tools appropriate for the specific tasks
  • Evaluate tool capabilities and limitations
  • Consider privacy and security implications
  • Ensure compliance with institutional policies

Team Preparation

  • Train team members on AI tool usage and limitations
  • Establish communication protocols for AI-assisted work
  • Define review and approval processes
  • Create templates for documentation and attribution

During Development

Prompt Engineering Best Practices

  • Use clear, specific, and detailed prompts
  • Provide sufficient context for AI understanding
  • Break complex tasks into smaller, manageable components
  • Iterate and refine prompts based on output quality

Quality Control Workflow

  1. AI Generation: Use AI tools to create initial content or code
  2. Initial Review: Quick assessment of output relevance and quality
  3. Technical Validation: Detailed review of technical accuracy
  4. Content Review: Verification of factual accuracy and appropriateness
  5. Integration Testing: Ensure compatibility with existing systems
  6. Final Approval: Sign-off by qualified human reviewer

Documentation Requirements

  • Record all AI tools and versions used
  • Document prompts and AI responses for significant contributions
  • Track iterations and refinements
  • Maintain version control with clear commit messages

Post-Development Review

Comprehensive Assessment

  • Evaluate overall quality and effectiveness of AI assistance
  • Identify areas where AI was most and least helpful
  • Document lessons learned and best practices
  • Assess compliance with guidelines and standards

Ongoing Maintenance

  • Establish procedures for updating AI-assisted content
  • Plan for regular review and validation cycles
  • Monitor for changes in AI tool capabilities or policies
  • Update documentation and attribution as needed

Specific Use Cases

Content Creation

Appropriate Uses

  • Generating initial drafts of documentation
  • Creating templates and boilerplate content
  • Structuring information and organizing content
  • Improving clarity and readability of existing text

Quality Assurance

  • Verify factual accuracy of all AI-generated content
  • Ensure consistency with institutional voice and style
  • Check for appropriate academic tone and language
  • Validate citations and references

Code Development

Appropriate Uses

  • Generating boilerplate code and templates
  • Creating CSS styles and responsive layouts
  • Implementing standard functionality and features
  • Debugging and optimization suggestions

Quality Assurance

  • Review code for security vulnerabilities
  • Test functionality across different browsers and devices
  • Validate accessibility compliance
  • Ensure code maintainability and documentation

Design and User Experience

Appropriate Uses

  • Creating responsive layout structures
  • Generating color schemes and typography suggestions
  • Implementing accessibility features
  • Optimizing user interface elements

Quality Assurance

  • Test with real users and gather feedback
  • Validate accessibility with automated and manual testing
  • Ensure cross-platform compatibility
  • Review against design principles and best practices

Risk Management

Common Pitfalls

Over-Reliance on AI

  • Maintain human expertise and critical thinking
  • Avoid accepting AI suggestions without proper review
  • Ensure human understanding of all implemented solutions
  • Balance efficiency gains with quality requirements

Inadequate Review

  • Implement systematic review processes
  • Allocate sufficient time for quality assurance
  • Involve multiple reviewers for complex components
  • Document review decisions and rationale

Attribution Failures

  • Maintain detailed records of AI assistance
  • Follow institutional attribution requirements
  • Update documentation as AI contributions evolve
  • Ensure transparency in all project communications

Mitigation Strategies

Robust Review Processes

  • Multi-stage review with different perspectives
  • Automated testing and validation tools
  • Regular quality audits and assessments
  • Continuous improvement of review procedures

Clear Documentation

  • Comprehensive tracking of AI tool usage
  • Detailed attribution and acknowledgment practices
  • Regular updates to documentation and guidelines
  • Transparent communication with stakeholders

Ongoing Education

  • Stay current with AI tool developments and best practices
  • Participate in professional development and training
  • Share experiences and lessons learned with the community
  • Contribute to the development of field-wide standards

Institutional Compliance

Policy Alignment

Institutional Requirements

  • Review and comply with institutional AI policies
  • Align with academic integrity standards
  • Follow data privacy and security requirements
  • Respect intellectual property guidelines

Disciplinary Standards

  • Adhere to field-specific guidelines for AI use
  • Follow professional organization recommendations
  • Maintain consistency with peer practices
  • Contribute to the development of community standards

Reporting and Documentation

Project Documentation

  • Include AI assistance in project reports and documentation
  • Provide detailed methodology descriptions
  • Document quality assurance processes
  • Share lessons learned and best practices

Institutional Reporting

  • Follow institutional requirements for AI use reporting
  • Participate in policy development and review processes
  • Contribute to institutional learning and improvement
  • Support the development of institutional best practices

Future Considerations

Evolving Technology

Staying Current

  • Monitor developments in AI tools and capabilities
  • Evaluate new tools and techniques as they become available
  • Update guidelines and practices based on technological advances
  • Participate in professional communities and discussions

Adaptation and Improvement

  • Regularly review and update these guidelines
  • Incorporate feedback from users and stakeholders
  • Learn from successes and failures in AI-assisted projects
  • Contribute to the broader conversation about AI in academia

Community Building

Knowledge Sharing

  • Share experiences and best practices with the academic community
  • Contribute to conferences, publications, and professional discussions
  • Collaborate with other institutions on AI guidelines and standards
  • Support the development of field-wide best practices

Mentorship and Training

  • Train new team members in AI-assisted development practices
  • Mentor other institutions in implementing AI guidelines
  • Contribute to educational resources and training materials
  • Support the development of AI literacy in academia

Resources and References

AI Tools and Platforms

Academic Guidelines

Best Practices Resources

Contact and Support

For questions about these guidelines or AI-assisted development practices:

  • Guidelines Questions: Contact the development team
  • Institutional Policy: Consult with institutional AI policy offices
  • Technical Support: Refer to tool-specific documentation and support
  • Community Discussion: Participate in relevant professional forums

These guidelines are part of the SFB 1252 "Prominence in Language" commitment to transparent and responsible use of AI in academic research and development.